San Giovanni 1915–1917: the hill of the Alpini

Between Passo Cinque Croci and Passo Val Zion, Col San Giovanni changed hands at least 13 times: an easy path leads among the remains of the fortifications.

Between Passo Cinque Croci and Passo Val Zion, Col San Giovanni changed hands at least 13 times: an easy path leads among the remains of the fortifications.

Where the isthmus linking the Cima d’Asta massif to the main ridge of the Lagorai dips to the 2,018 metres of Passo Cinque Croci, two rounded grassy rises climb gently on either side of the pass. The southern hill, known to most as Cima Socede, marks the end of the irregular crest that runs northwards from Cima Lasteati through the area of the small lakes of the same name. The northern rise, which separates Passo Cinque Croci from the nearby Passo Val Zion, climbs in steep grassy slopes into a camel-back shape, with two humps of almost identical height (2,251 m a.s.l.): this is Col San Giovanni, which between 1915 and 1917 was the focus of almost continuous Italian and Austrian military operations because of its commanding position astride the heads of Val Campelle and Val Cia. Over the course of the war, even leaving aside the Austrian withdrawal at the time of the final collapse in November 1918, the contested hill changed hands at least 13 times!

On the Italian side, almost exclusively Alpini units were deployed there, from the Val Cismon, Valbrenta and Feltre battalions, and by the end of 1916 the hill had well and truly earned the nickname “hill of the Alpini”.

1915: the attacks of the Val Cismon battalion

Incorporated as a permanent outpost into the Austrian line of resistance protecting the passes of the central Lagorai – Forcella Valdorda, Forcella Busa della Neve and above all Forcella Lagorai – Col San Giovanni was held in the summer of 1915 by a handful of Standschützen and Landsturmern of the “Gruppe Obst Radda”. The first attack fell to the Val Cismon battalion, then concentrated around Forcella Magna. As early as 31 July a patrol led by the then Lieutenant Cristoforo Baseggio had carried out a reconnaissance as far as Cima Socede (then point 2179); two days later, on 2 August, the same officer again led a party of 25 Alpini which, taking advantage of the fog, managed to occupy the hill, driving off its few defenders with rifle fire, but had to abandon it before nightfall because there was no link whatsoever with the main Italian line.

Immediately reoccupied by Austrian sentries, San Giovanni became Italian again for a few hours on 26 August, when two Val Cismon patrols, supported by the fire of a squad posted on Cima Socede, stormed its eastern slope under the command of Second Lieutenant Frescura in order to observe and survey from the summit the enemy positions of Stellune and Valsorda opposite. At 20:00 that same day, however, the Alpini returned once again to Forcella Magna, while from the following day the enemy set up a daytime-only advanced post on the southern hump.

Both the hill and Passo Cinque Croci were to remain in no man’s land for a long time to come, even though the period of almost bloodless clashes was over. On 17 September, during yet another attack on San Giovanni, the Val Cismon suffered the death of an officer. After a patrol had narrowly escaped an ambush laid for it between Malga Conseria and Passo Cinque Croci on the 13th, at 1:00 in the morning four patrols set out from Forcella Magna to attempt the usual capture of the Austrian daytime advanced post on point 2251; during the manoeuvre, near the knoll north-east of Malga Conseria, Lieutenants Palatini and Feruglio stumbled in quick succession onto two “land torpedoes”, a kind of buried anti-personnel mine triggered by a tripwire. The death of the first officer and the wounding of the second, who earned his first Bronze Medal of Military Valour in this action, did not halt the attack, which ended with the capture of a Bohemian soldier and the killing of two Landsturmern, although once again the hill was not permanently occupied. The next day the Austrian sentries were back in their places on point 2251-south.

Entirely bloodless and almost unopposed, on the other hand, was the attack that was meant to lead to the definitive occupation of the position, on 18 August, at the same time as the attack on Cima Valpiana. The action, aimed at pushing the Italian line forward between Val Calamento and Val Campelle to the alignment Valpiana–Setole–Malga Montaletto–La Costa–Col San Giovanni, failed because of Austrian resistance, which forced the Italians to give up Valpiana and dig in on the Setole. While below Valpiana the 265th company of the Val Cismon lost twelve Alpini (among them its commander, Captain Bianchi), the three platoons of the 264th company that climbed San Giovanni met almost no resistance. On that occasion the occupation was extended to Col della Palazzina, point 2114, lying below to the west, which at the time, owing to its proximity to the main hill, the Italians had named “San Giovannino” in their wartime place names.

November 1915: the Austrian attack and the snow

The Italians settled on San Giovanni, permanently occupying only the southern hump and posting only night sentries on the overly exposed northern summit. One hundred and fifty men in all manned the horseshoe-shaped trenches around Passo Cinque Croci. After a sudden shrapnel bombardment from Valsorda and Montalon had devastated the Alpini camp on the southern slope of the hill on 27 October, leaving three dead and six wounded, the defence of the position passed on 3 November to a single platoon of the 57th Infantry Regiment (Abruzzi Brigade). But on 8 November the inexperienced infantrymen did not hold out for long against the determined attack of a strong patrol of Hungarians from battalion II/29 and Standschützen from the Feldkirch battalion, who had set out by night from Forcella Lagorai. Wrapped in white cloaks and equipped with snowshoes, the Austrians burst onto the northern hump, spreading panic among the Italians, who fell back first to Cima Socede and then all the way to Forcella Magna. Losses were just two men, but the retreat left dangerously exposed the section of two 149G guns that gunners and Alpini had laboriously hauled up from Forcella Magna at the beginning of November and emplaced near the highest of the Lasteati lakes! In their retreat the infantrymen had naturally swept the gunners along in their panic, and now the intact guns, completely undefended and unguarded, lay abandoned in no man’s land a few hundred metres from the unsuspecting Austrian infantry. A whole infantry company was therefore hastily recalled from Val Sorgazza; the next morning, having reached the two “missing” guns, it rushed the hill and easily reoccupied it as the enemy quickly withdrew. The heavy snowfalls of early November convinced the Italians that there was no longer any danger of losing San Giovanni to Austrian attacks, which reassured the commands in the rear. But this time it was the forces of nature that compelled the occupiers to abandon it: on the evening of 11 November the last infantry patrols left the hill, as it was absolutely impossible to maintain even the slightest link with the line behind, and fell back for good to Forcella Magna.

Only daring Austrian ski patrols ventured onto the hill, covered by a thick, pure white blanket of snow, to observe between December 1915 and March 1916. And it was precisely these patrols that became the nightmare of the Italian command at Forcella Magna, obsessed by the fear that the enemy might beat it to the permanent reoccupation of the hill.

Spring 1916: the Strafexpedition on San Giovanni

After exhausted patrols of territorial militia had repeatedly tried in vain to reach the hill, on 17 April a patrol of the Valbrenta battalion finally established itself there, even setting up an efficient telephone link with Cima Socede and the rear. There was no lack of pleasant moments in this phase, as the letters of Second Lieutenant Paolo Marconi to his family show: “I would like to describe a dawn on San Giovanni, when in the clear sky, in a pale light, the rocks all around can be seen darting upwards in pure tranquillity. Then the snow clearly dominates everything. When the sun rises and gilds the highest crags, the all-white magpies take flight with their heavy beating of wings and their muffled cry, or the white ptarmigan that sing as they move on in wide and solemn flight. Then the sun comes down from the highest peaks to search the deep valley covered by the dense forest.”

The opening of the Strafexpedition north of Valsugana was marked, on the night of 15–16 May 1916, by yet another Austro-Hungarian assault on Col San Giovanni: some 600 men from the Auer and Feldkirch Standschützen battalions, as well as the 166th Landsturm battalion and infantry battalion II/29, wearing white camouflage smocks, set out under cover of darkness from Forcella Valsorda, crept silently to within a few dozen metres of the summit strongpoint and took it by surprise after a brief fight with the 90 Alpini of the Valbrenta holding it. Once again the Italians abandoned the whole Lasteati ridge, establishing themselves on the line Cima d’Asta – Forcella Magna – Cima Lasteati – Cengello and letting the enemy settle (24–25 May) not only on San Giovanni but also on Cima Socede and on the bare knolls around the Lasteati lakes (point 2079 I.G.M.).

With the beginning of June and the Strafexpedition grinding to a halt in Valsugana, the initiative returned to the Italians: on the 16th of that month the 263rd company of the Valbrenta launched an ill-fated attack on Cima Socede, aimed at retaking Passo Cinque Croci and Col San Giovanni. The operation, which required the belated support of the 264th of the Val Cismon to get Captain Buzzetti’s Alpini out of trouble (the fortnight’s balance: a sad fight that ended badly, with the old hands of the Valbrenta, on these knolls opposite, just to add to the haul of dead at the Malga Sorgazza cemetery – as Paolo Monelli described it in his “Le scarpe al sole”), failed because of stubborn enemy resistance, with the loss, among others, of two officers (Second Lieutenants Marconi and Campiglio-Lombardi).

1916-1917: the Italian strongpoint until the retreat

Col San Giovanni only became Italian again at the end of the counter-offensive launched by the Italians in the Cimon Rava massif from 3 July, aimed at driving the Austrians back west of the Maso stream: having lost the key positions of Cima Primalunetta–Cenon, the Tavarade ridge and Croz di Conseria, and in serious difficulty in the area between Osteria Crucolo and the Rio Brentana waterfall, the Austrians opted for a general withdrawal beyond the Maso on the night of 4–5 July. Cima Socede, Passo Cinque Croci, Col San Giovanni and San Giovannino, as well as the nearby Col degli Uccelli, by then indefensible, were thus abandoned. Dozens of Dalmatian and Ruthenian deserters surrendered to the Italian Alpini and infantrymen, but only on 6 July did the scout platoon of the Feltre battalion advance to occupy Col San Giovanni and the adjacent Malga Val Zion. On the evening of that day, as the platoon was preparing to return to Forcella Magna, the scout Luigi Barél, a veteran of the Libyan War and dear to Paolo Monelli, was accidentally killed on the hill through reckless curiosity about Austrian hand grenades.

Having become a fundamental pillar of the Italian line of resistance in the central Lagorai, Col San Giovanni was gradually transformed by Alpini and infantrymen into a formidable strongpoint defending Passo Cinque Croci, the extreme left wing of what, for the Italian command, had become the “region of the hills”: a long, deep trench running along the watershed of the pass itself linked it to Cima Socede; on the southern slope, covering the pass and the blockhouse built there, numerous loopholes of machine-gun positions opened out of caverns; trenches roofed with sloping wire netting against hand grenades connected the more exposed northern summit to the southern one; two small 42 mm rapid-fire guns and six machine guns, all nestled in little redoubts of concrete, earth and fir beams, kept under fire the Col dei Fiori opposite (point 2338), the first Austrian outpost beyond Passo Val Zion. A ring of multiple belts of barbed-wire entanglements enclosed the hill together with San Giovannino in a single 360° defensive structure, able to hold out for some time even if the link with Cima Socede were cut.

The end of 1916 and almost all of 1917 passed quietly, with sporadic bombardments and the occasional patrol action; worth mentioning in this respect is a surprise offensive reconnaissance in March 1917 by a platoon of the Val Camonica battalion, which outflanked and seized by surprise the Austrian post on Col dei Fiori, capturing prisoners and destroying installations. When the collapse of the Italian eastern front under the blows of the Austro-German offensive of October 1917, with its threat of encirclement, also threw into crisis the Italian defensive system in the Valsugana–Vanoi–Cismon sector, the planned withdrawal to the Grappa provided that the troops assigned to hold this massif would include the units that had until then occupied the Rava peaks, and which had only been informed of the imminent retreat at the beginning of November. Col San Giovanni was abandoned by the Alpini of the Valbrenta, who once again dug in temporarily in front of Forcella Magna, only on the night of 5–6 November. On the evening of the 6th the black-and-yellow flag of the Dual Monarchy was flying once more – and would do so for another very long year – over the scarred, gravelly summit of the “Hill of the Alpini”.

Visiting Col San Giovanni today

A visit to Col San Giovanni, together with the adjacent Passo Cinque Croci and Cima Socede, is within reach of even the laziest hiker: drive up from the floor of Valsugana (turn-off near Strigno-Agnedo) to the well-known Rifugio Crucolo on the left bank of the Maso valley, then continue through the pleasant Cenon basin, past Rifugio Carrettini, to the car park at the place called “Ponte Conseria” (no further driving without a municipal permit). From Ponte Conseria, SAT trail no. 326 leads in about forty-five minutes to Malga Conseria, from where a quarter of an hour or a little more is enough to reach Passo Cinque Croci (2,018 m). By the distinctive metal cross on the pass, which bears five smaller crosses on its arms and a moving prayer inspired by them, you can still see the remains of the small blocking redoubt built in 1917, as well as the long communication trench that ran north from it, climbing the whole southern slope of San Giovanni.

The climb up the steep grassy slope presents no particular difficulty and lets you see for yourself the scale of the fortification work carried out in 1916 and 1917. A few dozen metres below the summit, a loophole still bears the emblem of the Fiat machine-gun company that built the position, carved into the then still-fresh concrete. Past the last remains of huts and caverns you reach the rounded summit, which offers a superb 360-degree panorama over the battlefields. In five minutes, along an easy route on the level ridge, you reach the exposed northern summit (Italian outpost) facing Col dei Fiori beyond Passo Val Zion.

The descent can be made via the gentle slope of San Giovannino and the deep-cut Val d’Ornella which, wedged between the two hills and crossed by a cool, gurgling stream, leads back down to Malga Conseria. Even easier is a visit to Cima Socede, which can be climbed without any difficulty directly from Passo Cinque Croci, and where the remains of the military installations are still impressive today for their size and extent. You can thus walk the whole Lasteati ridge, among mountain pines, bilberries and rhododendrons, as far as the lakes of the same name, passing the rocky rises (point 2161 IGM) where Second Lieutenants Marconi and Campiglio-Lombardi lost their lives in June 1916. On the way back, the knoll of the dead is worth a visit: mentioned by Mario Mariani in his book “Sotto la naja”, it is a small hump, once entrenched and now covered in rhododendrons, just north-east of Malga Conseria. A cross made of metal barbed-wire pickets now recalls the old little military cemetery where the soldiers killed by the winter avalanches were laid to rest in the spring of 1917.

Want to see the places in this story? See the trail or visit the Exhibition.